Shelter Island Real Estate

Find your island retreat in Shelter Island, NY with Frontline Realty Group. Accessible only by ferry from Greenport or North Haven, Shelter Island is one of Long Island's most exclusive and peaceful communities, nestled between the North and South Forks. Over one-third of the island is protected nature preserve, offering extraordinary natural beauty. From waterfront estates to charming cottages, Shelter Island real estate is highly coveted. Whether you're seeking a summer escape or a permanent island home, our agents are your Shelter Island specialists.

Shelter Island - Town vs. County Stats

Avg Price in Shelter Island: $3,057,400 / County Avg $1,492,600

205%

Avg Taxes in Shelter Island: $8,800 / County Avg $21,800

40%

Avg Sq. Ft. in Shelter Island: 3,557 / County Avg 2,537

140%

Avg Price per/sqft in Shelter Island:$860 / County Avg $588

146%

Avg Year Built in Shelter Island: 1991 / County Avg 1973

101%

Avg Days on Website in Shelter Island: 136 / County Avg 88

155%

Shelter Island Real Estate Market Health

New Listings
Reductions
Foreclosures
Short Sales
Fair Housing Icon NY Fair Housing Notice